Capabilities
Industries
Quality & Engineering
Resources
About
Manufacturing Partner Evaluation Scorecard | Modus Advanced

Manufacturing Partner Evaluation Scorecard

Compare Modus Advanced against your current or potential manufacturing partners with this comprehensive evaluation tool designed for aerospace, defense, and medical device programs.

How to Use This Tool

Evaluate a competing manufacturing partner by rating them across six critical categories. Modus Advanced's scores are pre-populated based on our demonstrated capabilities. Rate your partner candidate using the same 0-5 scale, and we'll automatically calculate weighted scores to help you make an objective comparison.

Scoring Scale

0Capability not present / Requirement not met
1Minimal capability / Barely meets requirement
2Basic capability / Meets minimum requirement
3Adequate capability / Meets most requirements
4Strong capability / Exceeds requirements
5Exceptional capability / Industry-leading performance

Technical Manufacturing Capabilities

Weight: 30% | Maximum Score: 30 points
CNC Machining
Multi-axis capability with tight tolerance achievement (±0.05mm / ±0.002")
5
3
Industry Experience
Demonstrated case studies in defense and aerospace industry
5
3
RF Shielding & EMI Solutions
Complete RF shield production (housing + FIP gaskets + coatings) with high-temperature gasket materials and dispensing precision
5
3
Thermal Management
Thermal interface materials and barrier coatings
5
3
Elastomeric Converting
Multiple cutting methods (die, waterjet, CNC) with high-temperature elastomer experience (>250°C)
5
3
Surface Treatments
Coating/plating processes with validated adhesion and performance
5
3
Category Maximum
30
Modus Advanced
30.0
Your Partner
18.0

Quality Management & Certification

Weight: 20% | Maximum Score: 20 points
Core Certifications
AS9100 and/or ISO 9001 certification with clean audit history
5
3
Quality System Implementation
Documented QMS with first article inspection, in-process controls, and continuous improvement programs
5
3
Measurement Capabilities
CMM, optical measurement, and calibrated inspection equipment
5
3
Performance Metrics
Documented defect rates, on-time delivery (>95%), and effective corrective action systems
5
3
Category Maximum
20
Modus Advanced
20.0
Your Partner
12.0

Cybersecurity & Compliance

Weight: 15% | Maximum Score: 15 points
CMMC Compliance
CMMC Level 2 certification with NIST SP 800-171 controls and cyber incident response procedures
5
3
DFARS & Security Implementation
DFARS 252.204-7012 compliance with malware protection
5
3
ITAR Registration & Controls
Active ITAR registration with technical data protection and physical security
5
3
Category Maximum
15
Modus Advanced
15.0
Your Partner
9.0

Vertical Integration & Process Consolidation

Weight: 15% | Maximum Score: 15 points
In-House Process Breadth
Multiple critical processes under one roof (machining, coating, gaskets, converting) with assembly capabilities
5
3
Integration Benefits
Single point of contact, streamlined change management, consolidated quality control
5
3
Cross-Functional Engineering
Integrated engineering support across all processes
5
3
Category Maximum
15
Modus Advanced
15.0
Your Partner
9.0

Engineering Support & Collaboration

Weight: 12% | Maximum Score: 12 points
Engineering Team Depth
Engineers as percentage of total staff (target >10%) with relevant expertise
5
3
Design for Manufacturing Support
Early design involvement with comprehensive DFM reviews and tolerance analysis
5
3
Technical Communication & Problem-Solving
Designated engineering contacts, fast response times, and proactive recommendations
5
3
Category Maximum
12
Modus Advanced
12.0
Your Partner
7.2

Production Capacity & Scalability

Weight: 8% | Maximum Score: 8 points
Lifecycle Volume Support
Capability across rapid prototyping (1-10), bridge production (10-500), and high-volume (500+)
5
3
Scalability & Domestic Manufacturing
Proven scale from prototype to production with all operations in USA
5
3
Category Maximum
8
Modus Advanced
8.0
Your Partner
4.8

Overall Comparison Results

Modus Advanced

100.0
Exceptional Partner

Your Partner

60.0
Adequate Partner with Gaps
CategoryWeightMaximumModus AdvancedYour PartnerGap
Technical Manufacturing Capabilities30%3030.018.012.0
Quality Management & Certification20%2020.012.08.0
Cybersecurity & Compliance15%1515.09.06.0
Vertical Integration & Process Consolidation15%1515.09.06.0
Engineering Support & Collaboration12%1212.07.24.8
Production Capacity & Scalability8%88.04.83.2
TOTAL WEIGHTED SCORE100%100100.060.040.0

⚠️ Critical Threshold Requirements

Regardless of overall score, partners must meet these minimum requirements:

  • CMMC Level 2 certification (or active path to certification)
  • ITAR registration with documented technical data protection
  • AS9100 or ISO 9001 certification
  • High-temperature material experience (>200°C / >392°F)
  • Documented quality metrics and performance history

Score Interpretation

Get Started

Speak to an Engineer Today

Don’t take our word for it. Reach out and speak to one of our engineers about your part today and see the benefits for yourself. We strive to turn all quotes around 48 hours or less to get your part moving as quickly as possible.

Submit a Design