Nobody designs a part or device hoping it will be ineffective. But for some devices, effectiveness matters more than it does for others. A great example of that is an RF shield. These intricate and complicated devices keep devices working properly in a multitude of critical industries, and that’s thanks to RF shielding effectiveness.
In this post, the Modus team explores RF shielding effectiveness in detail — its definition and some common questions we receive on this complex topic. Read on to learn everything you need to know.
Modus makes RF shields that work. How? By putting quality first. Ready to stop worrying about RF shielding effectiveness and work with a manufacturer you can truly trust. Contact us today.
Visit the Modus RF Shielding Resource Center
RF Shielding Effectiveness: Defined
When you are discussing and planning an RF shield, RF shielding effectiveness is bound to come up. It’s an essential quality of the RF shield you’re trying to correct, and it’s essential that you understand exactly what it is. With that in mind, here’s the quick and simple definition of RF shielding effectiveness:
That’s it — it is pretty simple. However, don’t let the simplicity of the concept fool you into thinking it’s simple to design an effective RF shield. It isn’t. Creating an effective RF shield requires engineering and design expertise, as well as the highest-quality manufacturing processes, methods, equipment and materials.
RF Shielding Effectiveness FAQs
As you set out to design and manufacture an effective RF shield, you’re bound to have some questions. Modus has the answers. Below, we’ve compiled some of those answers. Don’t see your question answered below? Don’t hesitate to reach out to our team directly. We’ll be happy to help you out.
What Makes an RF Shield Effective?
An RF shield is effective if it can block and/or redirect enough RFI to keep the device it is protecting working properly. But how, exactly, does an RF shield achieve that?
The answer to that question depends on the design of the RF shield in question. For example, Faraday cages use a metal wire mesh to redistribute incoming RF signals around the exterior of the cage. On the other hand, solid enclosures can be made with reflective metals that bounce signals away from them.
Read Everything You Need To Know About RF Shielding
How Can an RF Shield Be Effective if It Has an Opening?
One hole in the bottom of a boat can sink it, so how can an RF shield effectively keep interference out if it has multiple openings? It’s a great question with a one-word answer: gaskets.
More specifically, RF shielding gaskets made with RF absorbing conductive materials are placed around openings in the RF shield enclosure to make sure no signal can slip through the cracks and interfere with the shielded part inside.
Why Worry About RF Shielding Effectiveness in the First Place?
This question translates roughly to: Why should I care? You should care about RF shielding effectiveness if what you are designing relies on passing electronic signals from one point to another — whether that’s via cable or through the air.
Why? Because RFI can degrade and interrupt those signals, which can cause problems that range from minor crackling in audio to major system malfunctions that can actually put lives at risk, depending on the industry in which you operate. An effective RF shield can keep those signals out and your device working as it should.
Which Industries Should Care About Having Effective RF Shields?
Any industry that creates electronic devices is likely going to need effective RF shields for at least a handful of applications. But the industries that most commonly deal with and design RF shields include the following:
- Aerospace
- Defense
- Telecommunications
- Mass transit
- Consumer electronics
- Medical devices
- Electric vehicles
- Satellites
How is RF Shielding Effectiveness Measured and Quantified?
RF shielding effectiveness is typically measured in decibels (dB), which represents the ratio between the incident signal strength and the transmitted signal strength through the shield. The higher the dB value, the more effective the shield.
Most testing follows established standards like MIL-STD-285, IEEE-299, or EN 50147-1, where measurements are taken at various frequencies. A professional testing setup uses signal generators, antennas, and spectrum analyzers to capture precise readings.
As a general reference point, 60dB of shielding effectiveness represents a reduction factor of 1,000, while 100dB represents a reduction factor of 10 billion. Most commercial applications require 60-90dB of shielding, while military and sensitive medical equipment often demand 90-120dB.
Does RF Shielding Effectiveness Vary Across Different Frequencies?
Yes, and this is a critical consideration in RF shield design. Most shields do not provide uniform protection across all frequencies. Typically, shielding effectiveness decreases as frequency increases, particularly at very high frequencies.
This variation occurs because different frequencies interact differently with shield materials and geometries. At higher frequencies, wavelengths become smaller and can more easily penetrate small openings or thin sections of the shield. That's why it's essential to test shielding effectiveness across your device's entire operational frequency range rather than at a single point.
Some materials perform better at specific frequency ranges, which leads engineers to often use composite shields or multiple shielding techniques for broadband applications.
What Materials Provide the Highest RF Shielding Effectiveness?
Material selection significantly impacts shielding effectiveness, with each material offering distinct advantages:
- Copper provides exceptional conductivity and offers excellent shielding across a wide frequency range. It's often the gold standard but comes at a higher price point.
- Aluminum delivers good shielding performance at approximately 60-70% of copper's effectiveness, but at a significantly lower weight and cost, making it ideal for aerospace applications.
- Steel and nickel alloys offer moderate conductivity but excel in magnetic field shielding at lower frequencies, where other materials might struggle.
- Silver-filled silicones and conductive elastomers are ideal for gaskets and create effective seals while maintaining the required conductivity across housing seams.
The optimal material choice depends on your specific frequency requirements, budget constraints, and environmental conditions. For critical applications, multi-layered approaches combining different materials often yield the best results.
What Are the Most Common Points of Failure in RF Shields?
Even the most thoughtfully designed RF shields can fail at several common weak points:
- Seams and joints where shield components connect represent the most frequent point of failure. Any gap larger than 1/20th of a wavelength can significantly compromise effectiveness.
- Gasket compression issues arise when gaskets aren't properly compressed or lose compression over time, creating small apertures that allow signal leakage.
- Apertures for cables, ventilation, or user interfaces often become unwanted entry points for RF interference. The rule of thumb is that a hole with a diameter of λ/20 (where λ is wavelength) can reduce shielding effectiveness by approximately 20dB.
- Material degradation through corrosion, physical stress, or temperature cycling can create microscopic cracks or change a material's conductive properties over time.
Addressing these potential failure points during the design phase will save significant time and resources compared to discovering them after production.
How Do Environmental Factors Affect RF Shielding Effectiveness Over Time?
Environmental conditions can significantly impact long-term shielding performance:
- Temperature fluctuations cause materials to expand and contract, potentially creating gaps at seams or reducing gasket compression. This is particularly problematic in aerospace applications that experience extreme temperature variations.
- Humidity and corrosion can degrade conductive surfaces, increasing electrical resistance and reducing shielding effectiveness. This is why proper plating and coating selections are crucial for shields deployed in high-humidity environments.
- Vibration in vehicles, aircraft, or industrial settings can loosen connections and create new gaps over time. Proper mechanical design with vibration dampening and secure fastening becomes essential in these applications.
- UV exposure can degrade certain conductive polymers and elastomers used in gasketing, slowly reducing their effectiveness over time.
For mission-critical applications, we recommend periodic testing to ensure shields maintain their effectiveness throughout their operational lifetime.
The Most Effective Manufacturers Make the Most Effective RF Shields
Knowing what RF shielding effectiveness is is only half of the battle. The other half is actually creating effective RF shields for the sensitive parts and devices you design. The effectiveness of an RF shield begins in the design phase, but the best RF shield design ever created could lead to an ineffective RF shield if the manufacturer messes it up.
That’s not just a theoretical concept, either, many manufacturers pretend that they know what they’re doing with RF shields but have no clue. They put out low-quality RF shields, and the result is ineffective or completely dysfunctional devices, as well as really unhappy customers.
That’s not us. Our team, which is made up of more than 10% engineers, puts quality above everything else. That’s how we manufacture some of the best RF shields across industries, from defense and aerospace to telecommunications and consumer electronics. By partnering with our customers and offering manufacturability feedback, we provide the best service in our industry. Not convinced? Try us. Give the Modus Advanced team a call at 925-960-8700 or contact us online today.
